Asking Judge to Reconsider
Hamilton County officials have decided they want a judge to reconsider his ruling in an eminent domain lawsuit that would provide additional parking in downtown Noblesville.
Superior Court 1 Judge Steve Nation ruled against the county in July in its attempt to obtain land through condemnation of McMillan's Auto Care in the 500 block of Conner Street.
The judge said the county's case was flawed because it failed to show how the property would be used or even why it was needed.
County commissioners filed a legal motion Friday to correct errors in Hughes' ruling. Chuck McMillan, the property's owner, has until Sept. 30 to respond to the motion.
In his initial ruling, Nation noted the county had access to 344 parking spaces leased from Riverview Hospital and said their availability made it less crucial for the county to take over the McMillan property.
-Governmental agencies all too frequently prevail in these uncertain cases of unknown or unjustifiable desire to take property.
Some day, the courts will really review whether the finding of a taking is indeed an error of law or abuse of discretion, a standard that all too often leads to a result where the government is perceived to make no mistake even though there is clearly a mistake.
